For a traditional look with paint I would choose one of the three neutral colors like beige, white or gray for the door. However, a stained wood finish would feel the most traditional and for the picture here would be the most appealing. Something like Early American or Danish Walnut.
Color Theory, LLC
Related Discussions
Need a new look for windows
Q
What Exterior Color for Cabin?
Q
Need help on bedroom
Q
Advice regarding color change for veranda
Q