I've seen it both ways..it depends on what you like and what you can accommodate..

It would be easier to say what would work better if your yard was photographed with a linear layout of the pool. Both will be beautiful if you use the design in the photos!!!

I opted for no spa and used a solar heater for the pool instead with spa jets on the side of the pool

Do you plan on covering the pool during the winter? If so, do you plan on leaving the spa open?

We live in Miami, Fl so the pool is open all year long. Thanks for the comments, I don't want to make a costly mistake and it's hard to know what looks best.

I had a raised because I wanted a waterfall effect from spa to pool.

I think the raised looks nice. Don't really see a "costly mistake" here, just two different ways to get a nice pool. Waterfall sounds neat.

Thanks all! It's only a costly mistake if I don't end up liking what I chose -- been there done that, lol. I think I like the waterfall effect more than I like the sleeker design of an all flush pool, I just didn't want to choose a design that was "dated" or not modern -- the pool company says that almost everyone doing a modern pool is choosing a flush spa, which makes me doubt myself.

If it were me, I would go with the flush spa and add the waterfall on the side so you can better enjoy from the house and patio . I would also forgo the sunning area to achieve more balance but also lounging being surrounded by water, its reflection can be very intense from a health and cancer perspective. I know that sounds depressing, but skin cancer is a big part of a few of my friends and relatives' lives and thought I would mention.

Great design!

I enjoyed mine at one level as we often went from pool to spa without having to get out. All a matter or preference.

Personally, Raised is always more of an attention getter. If you want to go with sleek, something flushed should be up your alley.

curious what you ended up doing....we are also in south florida and trying to decide the same thing.....

I like waterfalls. So I vote for waterfall. And I love the lounging beach. In fact, I could go with just the lounging beach and the hot tub. And, of course, a waterfall.

Beautiful concept design! I currently have a 15 x 43 rectangular with an in ground circular spa attached to the end. I have little deck space at the spa end of my pool. Looking to Remove the spa and place in the main pool to acquire more deck space. And possibly have an in pool Sun deck on pool as well.

You think will all fit?? Thoughts anybody!! Pool is 10 1/2ft deep and has a sitting bench at far end. 30years old.

Another photo from deep end of pool looking towards elevated putting green, BBQ area.

Seriously need an upgraded pool. Any advice would be Great!