J likes best. Y does not like the borders around the fireplace or above the fireplace. Y is ok with the stone/tile/material of the fireplace.
Q
Photo
J likes tile. Y does not like tile.
Q
Photo
We don't like this particular one, but a different with the white horizontal facade could work. Don't like the heavy black box around the fireplace itself.
Q
Photo
J likes this. Y does not like the part above the mantle, probably would prefer plain above mantle. Y would prefer more texture than this marble-looking facade.
Q
Photo
We don't disagree on this - it is somewhere between stone (Y's preference) and tile (J's preference). We would want a more iteresting mantle.
Q
Photo
J likes the tile. Y doesn't like tile.
Q
Photo
Y likes this facade below the mantle. J could live with this because it is not "too stony." Don't love this mantle, would prefer a natural wood look.
J likes best. Y does not like the borders around the fireplace or above the fireplace. Y is ok with the stone/tile/material of the fireplace.
Q